In Malaysia, the establishment and operation of trusts are governed by several legal frameworks, ensuring that trusts are used for legitimate and lawful purposes. However, not all trust purposes are permissible under Malaysian law. This article delves into the types of purposes for which trusts are prohibited in Malaysia and the legal implications of violating these restrictions.
-
Trusts Contrary to Public Policy
Trusts established for purposes that are contrary to public policy are prohibited. Public policy considerations include:
-
Illegal Activities:
Trusts cannot be established to fund or facilitate illegal activities such as drug trafficking, money laundering, or terrorism financing.
-
Immoral Purposes:
Trusts cannot be created for purposes considered immoral or indecent by societal standards, such as promoting pornography or other activities deemed socially unacceptable.
-
Discriminatory Practices:
Trusts that promote discrimination based on race, religion, gender, or other protected characteristics are not allowed.
-
Trusts with Unclear or Uncertain Purposes
For a trust to be valid, its purposes must be definite and clearly defined. Trusts with vague, ambiguous, or indeterminate purposes can be declared void. Trustees must be able to ascertain the specific intentions of the settlor to effectively manage and distribute the trust assets.
-
Perpetuities and Accumulations
Malaysian law restricts the duration for which trusts can exist through the rule against perpetuities. Trusts that are intended to last indefinitely without a clear endpoint or that accumulate income beyond a legally acceptable period may be invalid. This rule ensures that property does not remain tied up in trust indefinitely, preventing its productive use.
-
Non-Charitable Purpose Trusts
In Malaysia, non-charitable purpose trusts, also known as purpose trusts, are generally prohibited unless specifically authorized by statute. Unlike charitable trusts, which benefit the public or a segment of the public, non-charitable purpose trusts do not have human beneficiaries. Such trusts are typically allowed only if they serve legitimate purposes, such as the maintenance of graves or monuments, under specific legal provisions.
-
Fraudulent Conveyances
Trusts established with the intent to defraud creditors or to avoid legal obligations are prohibited. If a trust is created to shield assets from creditors or to escape liabilities, it can be challenged and set aside by the courts. Malaysian law, particularly the Insolvency Act 1967, provides mechanisms to address such fraudulent transfers.
Legal Implications of Prohibited Trust Purposes
1.Void Trusts:
Trusts established for prohibited purposes are deemed void ab initio (from the beginning). The assets intended for the trust are treated as if the trust never existed.
2.Trustee Liability:
Trustees who knowingly administer or manage a trust for prohibited purposes may be held personally liable. They could face legal penalties, including fines or imprisonment, depending on the severity of the violation.
3.Asset Recovery:
In cases of fraudulent conveyances, courts have the authority to recover assets transferred into the trust and return them to their rightful owners or creditors.
Conclusion
In Malaysia, establishing a trust requires adherence to strict legal standards to ensure that the trust serves lawful and legitimate purposes. Trusts created for prohibited purposes, such as those contrary to public policy, unclear or uncertain, violating perpetuity rules, non-charitable purpose trusts without legal authorization, or fraudulent conveyances, are deemed invalid. Settlors and trustees need to seek professional legal advice when creating a trust to ensure compliance with Malaysian law and to avoid the serious legal implications associated with prohibited trust purposes.
Are you doubtful whether any trust purposes are prohibited in Malaysia? Give us a call! As a reputable law firm, Sim & Rahman can advise you on all legal matters pertaining to trusts.
